Seduced by Two Page 5

  After dinner, I went upstairs and started putting my new clothes away in the dresser drawer that Andrew had cleared for me. I was just about done when I heard the bedroom door open. Heavy footsteps sounded behind me, and strong muscular hands wrapped around my waist, gripping me tightly.

  “You’re so sexy,” Andrew whispered in my ear. I blushed, turning around in his arms and tilting my chin up for a kiss. When our lips met, it was in a flurry of passion. Arousal and lust spiked in my blood as Andrew tangled his fingers in my hand, feeding on my open mouth. His tongue danced in my mouth and I felt my pussy tingling with excitement. Wrapping my arms around Andrew’s shoulders, I pulled him close and shoved my body against his muscular bulk.

  “Thanks,” I whispered softly when we’d broken away. My breath was coming in frantic, damp bursts and I shivered at the intense way Andrew’s eyes flicked over my body.

  “I don’t want to share you, Kristin,” Andrew panted. “I want you all for myself.”

  An elicit shiver ran through my body as Andrew stared deeply into my eyes. When we kissed, I pressed myself close to him. Somehow, it felt even more intimate just being with him alone than being with him and Victor at the same time. Andrew sucked and nibbled on my lower lip, making me moan deeply into his mouth.

  “God,” I purred. “Andrew, I want you.”

  Andrew’s hands slid under my sweater. He rubbed his thumbs over my swollen nipples and I gasped in pleasure as he began to pinch and pull at the stiff flesh. Arousal swirled through my lower body and I moaned. Andrew shoved a muscular thigh between my legs, pressing it against the crotch of my jeans. My pussy was on fire inside the silk panties and I eagerly ground against Andrew’s thick leg.

  The bedroom door burst open and Andrew and I leapt apart. I blushed madly as Victor walked into the room, smirking.

  “Hey, Kristin,” Victor said. “Come here.” He beckoned me with a finger. Desire and lust were swirling through my body, but suddenly I felt confused.

  “Damnit, don’t you knock?” Andrew asked angrily. “Come on, man. We were having a moment.”

  Victor frowned. “Kristin, don’t you want to kiss me?”

  I sighed and flopped down on the bed, feeling a confused blend of emotion and horniness.

  “I don’t know how to deal with you both,” I said hotly, shaking my head from one side to the other. My skin was still buzzing and itching for Andrew’s touch, but now that Victor was here, I had a feeling we wouldn’t get to pick up where we left off. The mood had been ruined. Even though I’d had incredible sex with both of them, and even though I’d picked out the lingerie for both Andrew and Victor, I couldn’t deny that somehow, being alone with Andrew almost felt more taboo than being with both men at the same time.

  “What are you talking about?” Victor crossed his arms over his chest and narrowed his eyes. “We’re both your friends.”

  “You’re fighting over me,” I said, blushing. “I’m sorry. I don’t mean to make things awkward, but it feels weird for me!”

  Andrew and Victor glared at each other.

  “You don’t have to play this game anymore, Kristin,” Andrew said. “You don’t have to do anything you don’t want to do.”

  I stared at him, loving the pleading look in his dark eyes. As much as I wanted to throw myself at him, I knew that I couldn’t. Tears welled up in my eyes and I bit my lip, glancing up at the ceiling so I wouldn’t cry. It felt incredibly weird to be crying when I was still horny.

  Everything was so mixed up. I didn’t know what to do.

  “Kristin, maybe you—“

  “Shut up,” Andrew hissed to Victor. “She’s upset, okay? Give her some space!”

  “I wasn’t demanding anything,” Victor snapped. “I just wanted her to hear my point of view. Kristin—“

  “Shut up,” Andrew growled, louder than before. “We should give her some space.”

  “No, I think she needs to finish talking—“

  “Shut up!” I screamed, jumping to my feet. “I can’t do this anymore!” I looked sadly from Andrew to Victor as my heart thumped loudly in my chest. “I have to go home,” I said softly. “This…this isn’t for me. I don’t think I can do it.”

  “Kristin, please—“

  “No, Andrew,” I said softly. “I’m too afraid of getting hurt.” I bit my lip. “I can’t let you break my heart.”

  Not knowing what else to do, I threw myself down on the bed and sobbed.

  Andrew drove me to the train station. We didn’t talk in the car – I felt awkward and uncomfortable around him, ever since I’d made the announcement that I was planning to leave.

  “Kristin, are you sure this is what you want?”

  I stared at him, my gorgeous stepbrother. What I want is you, I thought, afraid to say it out loud. Instead, I nodded my head slowly.

  “I think this was moving too fast for me,” I said quietly. “I’m not really the fast kind of girl, you know?”

  Andrew sighed. He reached for my hand, twining his thick fingers with mine and squeezing gently. The comfort was reassuring, but I knew that I couldn’t back down. Unless Andrew was willing to be with me and me alone, I couldn’t keep playing these dangerous games. I knew that somehow I’d wind up getting hurt.

  “It’s your decision,” Andrew said stiffly. “I respect that.”

  We pulled into the train station and I shifted awkwardly in my seat. Part of me wanted to throw myself across the seat and kiss him, but I knew I couldn’t do that – it would be betraying Victor.

  “Well, thanks,” I said softly. “I’m really sorry, Andrew. I didn’t know this would happen.” I sighed. “I just…I don’t want to get hurt. You can respect that, right?”

  Andrew nodded slowly. “You know you don’t have to leave, right? You can stay, Kristin. You don’t have to go back there – back to that den of wolves.”

  I wrinkled my nose, nodding. “I know.”

  “And when you’re really ready to leave again, you can come and stay with me,” Andrew added. “I don’t want you to feel like I’m upset with you for leaving.”

  I blushed. “I know,” I said softly.

  A train whistle blew loudly from the station, making me jump and squeak with surprise. Andrew laughed.

  “You’re so cute,” he said. He leaned forward and my heart skipped a beat. He’s going to kiss me, I thought in excitement. He’s gong to kiss me goodbye – he really does like me! But instead of a passionate kiss on the lips, Andrew’s mouth gently pressed against my forehead.

  “Bye,” I whispered. Tears filled my eyes as I grabbed my bags from the backseat and slammed the door. I kept wanting Andrew to follow me, to chase after me.

  But he never did.

  The train ride home was enough to fill me apprehension. I didn’t want to go back with my parents, but I knew that I really didn’t have another choice. After all, this was my fault. I was the one who had lied to my mom, regardless of how ridiculous the circumstances had been, and I was the one who was going to have to face the consequences of my actions.

  Hell, to be honest, I was surprised that she was letting me come home at all.

  Mom picked me up at the local station, an hour later. The air in the car was icy, and her lips were set in a tight line.

  “Mom, I’m really sorry I lied,” I said softly. “I didn’t mean to hurt you.”

  Mom heaved a huge sigh. “I know, honey,” she said. “But what you did was wrong. It’s a sin to lie to your parents.”

  For a brief second, I had the strangest urge to laugh. I knew that it was wrong – I knew, deep down, that Mom was right. But it was almost like my few days with Andrew had taught me something…that my mom was actually ridiculous.

  “Kristin?” Mom asked sharply. “Are you listening to me?”

  I blushed and sank lower in the seat. “Yes, ma’am,” I said quietly. “I’m listening.”

  The odd urge to laugh didn’t fade for the rest of the day. When Mom and I got home, I carried my stuff up
stairs and without thinking, shut the door behind me. An hour later, Mom was beating on my door and screaming angrily.

  “Kristin, if you don’t open this door right now, I’ll break it down! You won’t be allowed to have a bedroom door, do you hear me, young lady?”

  I got to my feet and yanked the door open just as Mom started beating both of her fists against the white-painted wood. She came stumbling into my room, gasping for air, her face bright red with anger.

  I couldn’t explain why, but suddenly, I had to bite at the inside of my cheeks to keep from bursting out into laughter. It was ridiculous!

  “You treat me like I’m a little kid,” I said pointedly, staring at my mom. “Weren’t you ever allowed to close your bedroom door when you were a kid?”

  My mom’s eyes flashed angrily at me. “Kristin,” she spat through clenched teeth. “You need to learn how to act like a proper young lady if you’re going to stay in this house,” she said angrily. “And respecting your parents is the best and first way to do that.”

  I frowned, narrowing my eyes. “It’s just a door,” I said blankly. “What the hell do you think I’m going to do in here by myself? Listen to music with curses?”

  The sting of my mom’s hand across my cheek was enough to make me cry out in pain.

  “Kristin, I don’t know what you learned out there on your own, but you’re in my home now,” Mom breathed angrily. “And you’re going to play by my rules.”

  Suddenly, Andrew’s face popped into my mind. It was the strangest thing – he’d used almost the exact same phrase shortly before I decided to come home. But he’d been telling me that I didn’t have to do anything I didn’t want to.

  Now, my mom was telling me the opposite.

  Dinner that night was even worse. Dean and Mom treated me like a kid – I wasn’t even allowed to serve myself, for fear that I’d drop the dish on the floor. It was fucking ridiculous. I didn’t know if they’d actually gotten worse, or if it was just in my mind. After all, I’d had a couple of days away from my parents. And I’d gotten quite the “education” about how different things could be in a house with no rules.

  “Kristin,” Mom said. “You’re coming to Bible study with me tonight. The theme is learning how to obey what God wants for us.”

  I rolled my eyes. “I have to study,” I lied. “I should be on track when I start the next semester.”

  “Then maybe you should have thought the better of lying to me,” Mom snapped. “You’re coming and that’s final.”

  I looked up at Dean, hoping to plead my case. “Dean, I really need to finish this paper,” I said. “Please?”

  Dean sighed. “Kristin, you lied about doing that before,” he said slowly. “Listen to your mother. She knows what’s best for you.”

  “But I’ll be right here,” I exclaimed loudly.

  Dean and Mom looked at each other.

  “I don’t know,” Dean said slowly. “Your mom rules the roost around here. You know that, kiddo.”

  Defeated, I slunk back down in my chair.

  Bible study was even worse than I thought it would be. The rest of the people there were young – like teenagers – and I was obviously the oldest one. Even worse, some girl asked me which high school I went to because she’d “never seen me around.”

  It was like my hot night in bed with Andrew and Victor was the most distant of distant memories.

  At home, I crawled into bed and turned out the lights, with my door wide open (of course.) Mom and Dean stayed up watching old reruns of Family Matters and then around eleven, they finally went to bed. As quietly as I could, I pulled my laptop out of my bag and booted it up.

  Without thinking too much, I wrote:

  “Dear Andrew,

  You were right. This is completely miserable, and it’s gotten even worse. I can’t stay here anymore. Were you serious about me being able to live with you?

  I miss you.

  Kristin.”

  I almost wrote “love” before my name, but decided that was too mushy and stupid. Besides, I was sure that Andrew didn’t feel the same way about me. He was a cool, older guy. He’d taken my virginity, and I was sure that was the extent of his affection towards me. It wasn’t like he was the kind of guy who fell in love, at least, that’s what I had to think. Andrew was too cool for things like love. Besides, I imagined if he loved anyone, it was probably Victor.

  I debated hitting ‘send’ for a solid ten minutes. Then I heard a cough from my mom’s bedroom, and the yellow glare of light appeared in the hallway. It’s now or never, I realized. I have to do this or else I won’t get the chance again. Nervously, I pushed ‘send’ and watched the email fade away, out of my inbox, towards Boston.

  “Kristin?” Mom was standing in the doorway, wearing a hairnet and glasses. “Why aren’t you asleep?”

  “Your cough woke me up,” I mumbled, turning on my side and facing away from the door.

  Mom sighed angrily, but she didn’t say anything.

  Finally, I fell into a deep, troubled sleep.

  In the morning, I went downstairs and turned the coffeemaker on. Normally, I wasn’t allowed to touch it, but the thought of Andrew rescuing me made the thought of punishment much more bearable.

  “Kristin, what are you doing?”

  I jumped a mile into the air at the sound of Dean’s voice.

  “Um, sorry,” I said quickly, blushing to the roots of my hair. “I wanted some coffee.”

  Dean glared at me. “You’d better not have broken this,” he warned. “This was a very expensive piece of machinery!”

  “Sorry,” I mumbled. “I really wasn’t trying to do anything wrong.”

  The knock on the door made me jump again. Dean turned to me, glaring.

  “Are you expecting anyone?”

  “Me?” I shook my head in surprise. “Of course not.”

  Mumbling under his breath, Dean went to answer the door. When he yanked it open, Andrew and Victor were standing there, holding a bottle of wine and a basket of fruit and chocolate.

  “Hey, Dad,” Andrew said, a huge shit-eating grin spread across his handsome face. “Long time no see!”

  When Dean recovered, he backed away from the door. For a moment, I was terrified that he’d tell Andrew to get the hell out of his sight – after all, I was shocked that Andrew had showed up with Victor. But when I saw Victor’s easy grin, I couldn’t help but relax.

  Thank God, I thought as Andrew and Victor kicked off their snow boots inside the foyer. They’re here to save me.

  “Hi, son,” Dean said tightly. “Why didn’t you call?”

  “Didn’t have time,” Andrew said casually. He pulled Dean into a big hug. “How are you?”

  Dean made a grumpy face. “I don’t like being surprised,” he said stiffly.

  “Mr. Medina,” Victor said kindly. “We thought you’d be happy to see us.”

  Dean looked at Victor like he was vermin. “Who are you again?”

  “Victor Gallo,” Victor said. “We’ve met. Twice, I think. But it’s nice to meet you again,” he added. “Thanks so much for not minding that we’re here!” Before Dean could wriggle out of the way, Victor pulled him into a tight hug. I hid a smile behind my hand.

  Andrew grinned at me. His eyes clung to my body in my thin nightgown and I blushed when I recognized the blatant look of lust on his handsome, Grecian face.

  “Hey little sis,” Andrew said. “How are you?” He pulled me into a hug, sliding his muscular hands over my body and down the curve of my back. When I felt him squeeze my ass, I cried out in delicious surprise. Arousal was flooding my body and I could practically smell the musky juices of my pussy as Andrew kissed me on the cheek. His stubble scraping against my sensitive skin made me shiver.

  “We’re here for a quick visit,” Andrew said, pulling away and grinning at Dean. “Hope we’re not putting y’all out!”

  Dean’s fake smile wavered, then disappeared completely. “I’m sure your stepmother won’t be
thrilled,” he said slowly.

  “Who, Carissa?” Andrew smirked. “She loves me.”

  “You will refer to my wife by her title, which is your stepmother,” Dean said frostily.

  “Or by her name, which is Carissa,” Andrew replied. I was astonished at the carefree, roguish way he talked with Dean. Slowly, I felt like I was beginning to understand why Andrew had chafed under Dean and Mom’s rule. But he was stronger than me – there’s no way Andrew would have put up with the same bullshit that I’d had to go through myself.

  “Who keeps saying my name?” Mom demanded, stepping into the kitchen and glaring. She was only wearing a thin robe over her nightgown and her cheeks flushed pink when she saw the pair of handsome men standing in her kitchen. Immediately, she turned to me and glared.

  “Hi, Carissa,” Andrew said. “Nice to see you. We brought breakfast,” he added, gesturing to the basket of goodies in Victor’s arms. “This is my friend, Victor.”

  Mom turned to me. “Kristin, get upstairs!” She barked loudly. “You’re not decent!”

  “We’re all family here,” Andrew said easily. I gasped again – I loved the way he was able to diffuse tension in the house. “I think Kristin’s fine.”

  “She looks great,” Victor added. His eyes draped all over my body and I blushed when he stared at my breasts. I could feel that my nipples were stiff, poking two small holes in the cotton of my nightgown. His attention made me feel naughty – just looking at him, I remembered how delicious his tongue had felt, lapping at my asshole.

  “Yeah, sis,” Andrew said with a smirk. “You look really great.”

  I blushed. “I’ll be back,” I said softly. “I’m going upstairs to change.”

  The buzz of voices continued while I tossed my nightgown over my head and wriggled into jeans and a sweater, wearing my new silk panties underneath. I wanted Andrew to come upstairs, to burst into my bedroom and throw me on the bed, but I knew that he wouldn’t try something like that with my parents around, watching us like hawks.

  When I went back downstairs, Mom, Dean, Victor, and Andrew were all sitting around the table, sipping at glasses of orange juice.